|
Having trouble with some
aspect of teaching? Join the club!
Teaching
is difficult because every child has different learning
experiences, learning styles, and abilities.
The following troubles
are a cross section of typical issues which crop up regularly whenever I
am working with parents and teachers in schools.
Make
sure that you have read Essentials of Teaching
before you go further.
|
Troubles
|
What to do
|
Notes
|
|
He hates reading to
me! I dread listening to reading every night! Reading always
ends up with tears!
|
Your life is about to change!
You need to read the section on
Listening to Reading
right now! |
So many parents tell
me that they dread the nightly reading session, and so does their child!
If there are problems
with reading it can upset the whole family. This issue needs to be
addressed urgently.
|
|
She has
difficulty following print and pointing to words when someone reads. |
This
is a developmental skill. It only develops with experience. Use cut
up sentences or
‘Transformations’ to overcome this little hurdle.
Click here to see more about
this great activity. |
Your child will also
have difficulty counting and touching each object. It is part of the
same skill. |
|
He reads stiltedly, word by word |
Children don't teach themselves to read like this. They are taught
to read stiltedly by the adults who hear them read!
When we tell a child to look more carefully at the print or pull them up
when they make a mistake when reading to us, they learn several things:
What we should be teaching them are:
-
mistakes are normal and expected
-
the
best readers make mistakes, called miscues
-
when we read fast we know that we will make some changes to the text
-
look well ahead of your voice to keep the reading fluent
-
fix
up any mistakes that don't sound right
Teach your children these things. See
Listening to Reading |
Finger pointing can become voice pointing and will slow down reading. Try
reading without using the finger to follow every word. Just put the
finger at the beginning of each line.
If your child is still having trouble getting away from word by word
reading use a technique I call ‘chasing’ to force increased eye-span.
|
|
Phonics knowledge is poor |
Phonics knowledge is probably poor because his/her reading
progress has been slow and the child is an inexperienced reader and
writer! It doesn't happen the other way around! The kids who
are best at phonics are the best readers. Phonics is very difficult
for kids who are not reading well yet. Reading and
writing happens first, and secondly comes the need to analyse words and spell.
Phonics is a
spelling aid, not an essential tool for reading.
Having said that,
it is
essential for every child to learn about phonics to be an accomplished
writer and reader! The phonics eventually helps with decoding, but this is
a secondary skill overlaying the primary skill of reading using a
combination of language and meaning cues as the base. It is the order in which
things happen that is crucial. Phonics is easier to learn when you
have a need for it, such as when you are learning to spell or write, or
decoding a word. Teach it as needed, when it is needed.
For specific ideas on teaching
phonics click here.
|
The most damaging thing that can happen to a child who is
struggling with reading is to try to teach
them by focusing on the phonetic
aspects at the expense of language and meaning based strategies.
These are the kids I
see as 12 years olds who are in desperate trouble, having spent many years
being schooled in phonics but who still can't read or write effectively.
To increase your general understanding about the reading process make sure you read
Reading Assessment |
|
Lacks confidence in him/herself |
Always try to guarantee success. Do not try to teach things that are too
difficult for your child to understand or do.
Watch what the child can do, and keep working on that for a
while. Then tackle something he/she almost understands, or can nearly do and teach
that next. Successful, positive learning experiences build up confidence.
See Essentials of Teaching |
Successful learning experiences are critical for building
confidence. |
|
My
child won't
take risks with learning new things |
Reward the attempts to do things even though they
may not
be successful. Don't persevere in trying to teach something the
child is not ready for. Watch what he/she can do, and build
on those things. See
Learning Style
and
Essentials of Teaching |
The
personality of the child is evident quite early (before 2 years). If
your child is not a risk taker it is even more important that you pay
attention to building up his/her self confidence.
|
|
Can't or won't attend to things long enough to learn
|
Make a list of the child's interests and see if you can get
him/her to attend to those things first.
It is likely that
your child is avoiding attending to the things you want
because s/he is uncertain about it, lacks confidence to do it, has tried
it before and not been successful, and so on. Make sure you
understand Essentials of Teaching and
be patient. You will have to model the behaviours for the child and
make it 'safe' for him/her to try again. |
Students pay attention to what they are already familiar
with and understand.
Is concentration to watch TV OK?
Children avoid attending
to things which have proved to be too difficult in the past.
You have to find a way
for the child to be successful at this task, make a fuss, and see if this
helps the attending.
Check. Maybe the child hasn't the
background experience to understand or do this task? |
|
Becomes very anxious when trying to learn something new |
Reward all attempts and reassure child that
its OK to try new things- we all make mistakes.
If necessary let your child see you make some mistakes on similar tasks.
See
Learning Style |
Anxiety diminishes ability to attend so endeavour to reduce
the anxiety by designing tasks the child can do. |
|
Has
delayed language skills |
Maintain language activities such as structured play with another child.
Include free play with lots of materials which promotes exchange of
language.
Materials which could be used include
old clothes for dress-ups,
tea party sets with tables and chairs, soft animals,
telephones, prams
or pushers, blankets and furniture for building cubby houses. Try to
organise things that require two children to work together on tasks that
both have seen and know well such as household activities. |
From birth children need lots of experience of language such as talking,
singing, rhymes, stories (for book language), and playing with other
children in co-operative ways. |
|
Has problems with speech |
See Speech
Pathologist for a specialist program designed to help your child. |
You
are an integral part of any speech program because you will need to carry
it on at home. |
|
Loses track when
retelling stories, rhymes, or songs. |
Sing, read stories and practice rhymes and songs together every day. |
This is usually a matter of experience and it may take some
time (perhaps months) of perseverance but it will work if you insist and
are consistent. |
|
Sings the alphabet but misses letters or runs letters together. |
Sing it together. Use a tape recorder and tape your voices
for the child to play back as often as needed. |
Try using an alphabet chart and touching each letter as you
sing. |
|
Tries
to play 'I Spy' but is confused about starting sounds |
Continue to play
the game with your children and accept what the younger ones do.
Help by giving extra clues such as it starts with t, ta, tab... yes
table! Accelerate development by using picture activities to focus
attention on certain sounds.
eg. Use two pictures - a cat and a dog. I Spy the one that starts
with/sounds like a 'c'....... |
This ability comes with maturity and experience with language
and listening. |
|
Becomes confused when instructed to do
something. |
Have you had the child examined by a paediatrician or child
psychologist? This should be first step if you think it is a serious
problem.
Try
giving only one instruction at a time. Play barrier games
where you are both seated either side of a table with a low barrier
between you. Take it in turns giving and receiving instructions such
as in drawing or building things. |
Keep things simple and be clear in what you say and how you
say it.
Use
simple language. |
|
Has difficulty identifying initial-final-medial
sounds in given words |
For initial sounds you could try matching letters and pictures.
Make up two sets of cards, one with alphabet letters and one set with
pictures to match the initial sounds. Begin with three matching
pairs to sort out and progress from there.
Click here to see more on the Elkonen
Technique which is excellent for training the ear to hear medial and
final sounds. |
The Elkonen tecnique uses
visual placeholders to show where to listen. It is a
listening technique and should be used without text. |
|
When trying to read points to the pictures, not the text. |
Read to the child and demonstrate
where you are looking by pointing to the text. Take the child's
finger and help him/her trace the text as you read. |
|
|
Sometimes starts at the right
hand side of the page with reading and/or writing. |
Read to them and demonstrate by pointing where you start.
Write with them and demonstrate how to do it. Sometimes it is useful
to find or put a mark on their left hand so that they will remember the
side to start on.
|
This
is normal behaviour for very young or inexperienced readers and writers.
It
doesn't mean that the child is Dyslexic!
See
Dyslexia article |
|
Not
sure where to go to the next line when the end of the upper line is
reached.
Sometimes starts at the bottom of the page?
Sometimes starts to read from the back of the book? |
These are all part of the same problem which is
inexperience with books and reading. Demonstrate by reading to and
with the child using your finger to point out where you are looking and
how the print flows from left to right, the return sweep to the next line
and so on to the bottom of the page. |
Although it is rare to find this in older children do not overlook the
possibility that this could be the problem. I once found a 8 year
old like this. He had been in school three years and no one had
picked it up! |
|
Physically uncoordinated with running, jumping, skipping, throwing,
kicking, etc |
Enrol your child in a 'Gross Motor Coordination Program' if
there is one at your local school. Also, ask your local GP whether a
referral to a specialist such as an occupational therapist is required? |
|
|
Has
difficulty controlling a pencil or crayon for drawing or writing |
This 'fine motor' hand control is a developmental skill
which generally improves with experience. Teach how to do it by
demonstrating and giving the child plenty of drawing materials to practice
with. Use large sheets of paper and crayons at first to get the
bigger actions such as back and forth, up and down, circles in both
directions, and so on. Then use a soft pencil with smaller sheets of
paper to get the feel of pushing and pulling and circles and shapes.
Stencils are useful here too, but get the ones with cut outs in the middle
so that the pencil can't 'escape'. These are good for teaching about
squares, circles, diamonds, and so on because they show the child how to
feel the corners, how to feel 'squareness' or curves, or small circles.
When it comes to writing
letter shapes
show the child where to start, and how to plan ahead about
where the pencil wants to go next. |
Self-talk is very useful here. Begin by talking the
child through the sequences as a letter is formed.
"You do a 'b' like this. Start at the top, come down to the bottom,
then up. around to the right and back to the stick to finish the circle."
Teach the child to say
the sequences for letters that are needing extra care. |
|
Grips pencil in whole hand rather than fingers |
Teach how to grip. Use a thicker pencil at first and
place his/her fingers on the pencil, or try using a triangular plastic or
rubber grip until the child has mastered the grip without it. |
Pencil grips help the child learn where to place their
fingers. |
|
Writes letters and numbers backwards |
See
the article on Reversals for more
on this subject.
Briefly, here are a few things to try. Teach where to start
and talk them through the construction of the letter or number. Find an ‘anchor’
which is something known which can be used to
aid memory. For instance, a child who always does a capital B
correctly but reverses the b/d every time can be show how to use the 'B'
as a memory 'anchor' to get the 'b'. They are very similar because
the 'stick' is on the same side.
Secondly try teaching
the muscles of the hand to do the 'b' automatically. Do this by
showing how to write the 'b' quickly. Write it dozens of times
quickly. Don't worry what it looks like as long as the principle of
its construction is sound. Then do it with eyes shut! Do it in
the air! Last of all do it carefully on paper!
|
Use
these same principles for any letter or number.
This doesn't mean that your child is
Dyslexic!
See
Dyslexia article |
|
Has
trouble recognising letter names
or sounds |
Sing the ABC song and make sure the child can play 'I Spy'.
Then use an alphabet chart
to link with the song and sing and point at the same time. This will
sort out any confusions and also show the child how to work out any letter
just by singing and touching the letters or pictures. Paste the
chart to their desk and use it when writing to find the required letter
sounds. The child now becomes aware that every letter has a name and
a sound.
See
Alphabet Activities |
Young children seem to be able to memorise names before letter sounds. |
|
Recognises or reads only a few words |
Focus first on reading more rather than teaching words.
See Listening to Reading
for more information. This is the main game.
Secondly, support their reading with a regular dose of sight words
beginning with the most common words first. Put five words on cards,
making two cards for each word. Then teach the child to play 'Concentration'
with them. Replace learned words regularly, ensuring that the child
is never overloaded. Demonstrate their progress by marking off words
learned on a chart such as the 'Salisbury'
or 'Dolch' lists' |
Use
familiar words (names, pets, hobbies, interests). Use Word list to check.
Play ‘Concentration’ |
|
Child doesn't seem to listen to his/her own reading, forcing adults to
point out errors |
This is probably happening because you started out helping to find the
errors and the child now relies on you to keep on doing it.
There is no reason why the child can't find their own errors and correct
them. Have a talk to your child about this and let him/her know that
you won't be telling when a mistake happens in future.
When you see a mistake happen next time, don't say anything
and see what happens. Let the child keep reading at least to the end
of the sentence and see if they can detect the error. If it made
sense the chances are that he/she won't see it or hear it. If it is
that minor you should let it go. Wait until you see an error (a
miscue) which doesn't make sense. If the child doesn't pick this up
ask, "Did that sentence make sense to you?" Keep working on that
theme of making sense, or 'sounding right'. It is easier for the
child to monitor for reading which 'sounds right'.
See the articles on
Assessing Reading and
Listening to Reading
|
To
find out more about this click here to see
solving reading problems |
|
Child stops on problem words but rarely works out the word! |
It
is time to teach some new strategies. There are many ways to solve
problems. Here are some starters for when a problem word is
encountered.
Tell your child to:
-
miss it out, leave it, keep going
-
keep going and come back to that one later
-
say a word that will fit and keep reading
What happens then is interesting. The reader will usually come back
and correct the word accurately because they have picked up more clues
about the word from the words that come after the problem
word.
If
you haven't done so you should read the section on
Listening to Reading
as there is even more that you can do before reading even begins.
|
Other
strategies to try are:
-
read it again from the beginning
-
use the first letters of the word to 'guess'.
(the term 'guess' is understood by the child but in reality the
technique is prediction based on prior knowledge, the language
syntax, and dialogue semantics).
|
|
Makes silly mistakes and says words that don't make sense |
This happens when children lose the idea that reading is
about everyday language, should sound sensible, and should
only use
words that are already known. Some children think that there are so
many new words that they have never heard before, so they try to make new
words up when reading.
To teach them about
sensible language a great activity to use is 'Bionic
eyes' or 'Oral cloze'!
Just pick up a book and begin reading so that they can't see the print,
but stop at an obvious word and ask the child what it is. eg. "Who's
that tramping over my _______?" When the child says "bridge" you are
entitled to ask, "How did you know that? You can't see the book!
Have you got Bionic eyes?" Continue the charade using words that are
entirely predictable at first, and later varying the words you stop at,
including some that rely more on knowledge of the English language
structure (grammar or syntax) such as:
"Who's that tramping
______ my bridge?"
"He picked __ the beans...."
"Red Riding Hood set off for ___ grandmother's house."
"He ran all the _____
home."
"He loved his mother be-______ she was
kind __ ___.
Note that the predictions can extend to
many words at a time.
|
If
a child learns that they can solve
problems without looking at the print, then how much easier will it be
when they are also able to see the print! |
|
Selects inappropriate books that are too easy |
This
happens because the child wants to be able to read to you successfully.
They figure that its safer to select easy books because they will make
fewer mistakes and you will be proud of them. It may also be because
there are things happening at school which could be embarrassing if a book
was too hard to read! Check it out with the teacher.
You need to teach them
that mistakes are OK. They are normal. Everyone makes mistakes
when they read. Daddy. Mummy. Teacher. Even the Principal!
Then you must look at
what is happening when people (including you) listen to him/her read.
Read Listening to Reading. |
Children should be able to select books which are just right for them.
They may need some guidance such as having a box of books to select from
which are all of similar difficulty. |
|
Selects books that are too hard or not suitable |
It
isn't normal for children to do this continually. It will happen
from time to time with inexperienced readers but most will soon sort out
what they can manage and what is 'hard'.
However, there is one
group of children who will always select books which are too hard to read.
These are the children who would be embarrassed to have a book they can
read on their desk because the other kids would say that it's too easy,
it's babyish, a beginner's book! For children who are struggling
this is a real problem. Where this is a big problem I encourage such
children to borrow two books at a time. One is a 'pretend' book,
which goes on the desk for show. The other, the real book goes in
the bag and is read at home. Now I know that this is a bit less than
perfect, but when their whole social standing is at stake I think that it
is worth it. Children have feelings too, right? |
Sort books into boxes based on ability levels to help
children choose suitable books more easily. |
|
|
|
|